KSC Instructional Technology

11.14.2006

Copyright & Fair Use, by Instructional Technology Liaison Linda Farina

I recently had the opportunity to attend a day-long workshop on copyright law. That probably doesn’t sound very exciting to you, but I was excited to think I would be coming back to KSC with some tangible information that I could share with all of you.
Unfortunately, what I came away with was confusion.

Copyright law is pretty straight forward; you create something, you own the copyright to it. If someone wants to use it, they need your permission. Sounds simple, right?

Wrong. There is something called fair use that complicates the simplicity of copyright law. As the name implies, fair use allows users to ‘fairly’ use someone else’s creation without asking permission. Unfortunately, it isn’t black and white and doesn’t necessarily make your life easier. You still need to do some research to find out which situations fall under fair use before knowing for sure that you won’t be violating copyright law.

I would say most people honestly believe they are following the guidelines of fair use when creating their own personal materials, especially when they are creating curriculum materials. However, even with their good intentions, this isn’t always the case.

Try answering the following true or false questions for a better understanding of your copyright and fair use proficiency. You’ll find the answers at the end of the quiz.

1. You scan every picture in a book to use as a handout in your class. The book is out of print, therefore there is no need to ask permission to use the pictures.

2. You don’t need permission for work that doesn’t have a copyright notice.

3. You recorded a PBS program off TV last night and plan to show it in its entirety in your class today. Before you show it, you need permission.

4. You write a poem on a napkin in a restaurant while waiting for friends to arrive. The waitress clears the table, including the napkin with the poem. She later publishes the poem as her own and makes a lot of money. There is nothing you can do about it.

5. A professional photographer took a picture of your grandfather years ago. You would love to give a copy of the picture to each of your siblings, but it’s the only one you have. So, you go to the nearest photo shop and ask to have it copied. The photo shop will probably turn you away because you don’t have permission from the photographer.

6. You create a PowerPoint presentation for one of your classes. You want to include a few images, so you go to a website that allows you to ‘right click and save’ the pictures to your desktop – now all you have to do is insert them into your PowerPoint presentation. Because nothing was blocking you from doing this, the pictures are legal for you to use.

7. The author of a book you love has just died. You can now use that book, or parts of the book, any way you’d like; without permission.

8. You can use a piece of work someone else created and incorporate it into your own work without acquiring permission.

Answers:

1. False. A book may be out of print, but in most cases SOMEONE still owns the copyright. It is up to you to contact the rightful owner for permission.

2. False. Copyright notices have been optional since March 1, 1989. A copyright symbol isn’t necessary to guarantee the material is copyright protected. In other words, you must assume everything is copyright protected. And to protect yourself you should make sure to get permission from the copyright holder.

3. True. Just because you pay for cable or a satellite dish doesn’t mean you own the right to whatever is being aired. You need to contact the producer of a program before showing it in class. Most of the programs that you borrow from a library that originally aired on TV were purchased with rights to show that program in a classroom setting.

4. True and false. Legally, once you’ve created it you became the copyright holder, so it is rightfully yours. However, proving it will be quite difficult.

5. True. The photographer owns the rights to the photograph. If the photo shop makes copies they are violating copyright.

6. False. Just because you can doesn’t mean you should – or that it’s legal. It’s best to ask permission.

7. False. Copyright lasts 70 years beyond death. It may be a little more difficult getting permission, but it is still your responsibility to do so.

8. False. You can create a derivative work from another, but without the owner’s permission you may have violated copyright law.


How did you do? If you’re like most people you probably scratched your head a few times. Unfortunately, copyright law and fair use guidelines are not straightforward. It requires some time and effort on your part to make sure you protect yourself and others. Educational institutions are not immune from copyright infringement suits, so be an educated educator.

For more information about copyright law and fair use guidelines check out http://www.utsystem.edu/ogc/Intellectualproperty/cprtindx.htm or the numerous other sites available on this subject.

And don’t forget, you’re invited to a brown bag lunch on Thursday, November 16th from 12:30-1:30 in Rhodes Hall, room 203. The topic: Copyright in the Digital Age.

11.13.2006

11/06 Technology Tool Pick of the Month

Imagine that you are teaching a course on evolution and genetics concept mapping. Your students are having difficulty grasping gene variation and mutations; the key concept behind your lecture. You’re in dire need of some fresh material to better help your students grasp this obscure concept. Enter MERLOT.

MERLOT is a free database of educational material designed primarily for faculty in higher education. The power of this site stems from resources, peer reviews, comments, and assignments submitted by the MERLOT community.

You visit the MERLOT website (merlot.org) and search for “DNA” and hope that it will yield some results. “DNA from the Beginning” is the first resource listed (of 139) and has the “MERLOT Editor’s Choice” stamp. You notice that this resource is a simulation and includes peer reviews (5 stars on a 1-5 scale), comments (8 comments), assignments (4 peer-submitted assignments), personal collections (131 people ‘bookmarked’ this resource), and an author snapshot (the rationale for developing this learning resource and the strategies for using it).

You decide to integrate the simulation and one of the peer-submitted assignments into your course. You now have new, peer-reviewed material to supplement your lecture!

Visit MERLOT to see the breadth of subjects covered. Resources from Music, Art History, Statistics, Marketing, English, Chemistry, etc. have material submitted to the database.

Testimonial from the MERLOT web site:
“One of the best things I appreciate about MERLOT is that is a collaboration of “like minds.” The organization continues to grow and develop at a global level, but this growth and development is driven and designed from within. When those invested in the effort, everyday members and editorial board members, have this ownership then the organization will have a long, happy, adventurous life.”
Cris Guenter
Professor of Education
California State University, Chico

11.09.2006

Copyright in the digital age

Thursday, November 16, 12:30-1:30 Rhodes Hall room 203. A brown bag discussion with Library Director Irene Herold

Fair use is a convenient benefit of copyright law, particularly in an academic setting. Fair use allows educators to bring content to students that they might not have common access to. However, exactly how much content an educator is entitled to under fair use, or what form the content can be presented in, is often misunderstood. Use of copyrighted materials in a digital environment adds another layer of complexity in applying fair use.

There are really three pieces to the copyright puzzle, according to Library Director Irene Herold.

  • What is the law?
  • Where can I find resources on the law?
  • What licensed content is currently available for me to use to keep within the law?

Unfortunately, copyright law isn’t clear cut. Learn where to find resources to help you understand copyright and fair use, and how the use of the Internet, Blackboard, and other institutional repositories complicates the issues of content distribution and access.

As more people start posting original content online, they can also use their understanding of copyright to protect or properly share their own creations.